After Rebirth I Married My EX- Husband's (Enemy Laurel)
Chapter 84

Chapter 84 Tina Is Punished

Tina's grimacing, contorted, and embarrassing appearance presented itself in front of the entire Gilbert family. No one had expected that this gentle, obedient, and kind girl could be so malicious.

Even though she is now so fragile and helpless, in their eyes she deserved it.

Remembering how they had been deceived by Tina all these years, a wave of anger surged within them.

Phillip was very angry at that moment.

He was very shocked.

Tina was not only malicious, but she also had disgustingly dirty thoughts...

Throughout his life, Phillip was involved in scheming and plotting in the business world, but always with the intention of benefiting his family without violating any major principles. He never did anything morally wrong or harmful, and yet now he has a daughter who is behaving so immorally.

"Get the whip!" Phillip shouted fiercely at the se rvant.

Whip!

The whip symbolized punishment.

Once someone made a big mistake, they would be publicly

punished.

From childhood to adulthood...

Only Hayden has been punished among them once.

That time, Hayden learned a very serious lesson. He lay in bed at home for a whole week and couldn't leave. Now...

It was Tina's turn to receive punishment.

At the moment Tina heard what Phillip said, she was scared.

She could still recall the gruesome scene when Hayden was whipped back then.

She still remembered the diary she had written at that time, in which she wrote that she wanted to kill Phillip. However, now.

She had to accept the punishment.

No!

From childhood to adulthood, although Tina has undergone countless surgeries, she always used anesthesia. Once the anesthesia wore off, even a little pain was unbearable for her. She would ask the doctor to administer anesthesia again. How could she endure Phillip's whipping?

Tina quickly got up from the ground in fear. She grabbed Marlene's clothes and said, "Mom, I don't want to be beaten by Dad. No, I don't want to."

Chapter 14 Tina is Punished

288 Moucher

Marlene felt both uncomfortable and angry at the moment.

Marlene raised Tina. Seeing Tina in such pain, she naturally felt heartbroken. But when she realized that Tina had so many dirty thoughts and a malicious heart, Marlene couldn't help but wish to punish her. "Mom, I was wrong. I know I was wrong. I will never dare to harm anyone again. I will never like Hayden again. Mom, I don't want to be beaten by Dad. My body can't withstand his beatings. He will kill me. Mom, please save me..." Tina burst into tears.

At this moment, Tina looked so pitiful.

However, Marlene did not compromise at all.

She looked at Tina coldly and didn't say a word.

"Mom, you don't want me to die, do you? Mom, you don't want me to die... After all these years, you have worked so hard to raise me. Every time I get sick and have to be hospitalized or taken into the operating room, you suffer so much. You wouldn't just stand by and watch me be beaten to death by Dad. Mom..."

"Enough!" Marlene pushed Tina away.

Tina looked at Marlene with disbelief. She couldn't believe that her mother, who loved her so much, would treat her like

this.

"Every time you fell ill, I felt it was my fault. Every time I saw you entering the operating room, I blamed myself for not giving you a healthy body. I wished I could give you my life. But now, I would rather you be beaten to death. I no longer

Chapter 4 Purished

11 283 Mouchers

want to see you in such a miserable state, using my pity/and indulgence."

Tina didn't believe.

Did not believe.

Her beloved mother would also say such words.

He would also show a disgusted expression towards her.

Tina was devastated to the extreme.

Tina shook her head, feeling as if she had been abandoned by the whole world in that moment. She screamed in madness, "I have become like this, isn't it because of all of you? Isn't it because you didn't give me a healthy body? I have been locked up at home since I was little. I can't go out like normal. people. I can't run, make friends, or fall in love. I can't do anything. I have to endure the torment my body inflicts on me, isn't it all because of you? Shouldn't I hate you? Shouldn't I blame all of you? Why can you all be healthy and I can't? Why can you do so many things while I can only suppress myself?" Tina's roar startled everyone.

This expression made everyone feel that their love for her was

all in vain..

"Yes, I do like Hayden. I really do!" Tina admitted. Her tone sounded defiant, "But is it my fault that I like him? No, it's your fault! I've grown up like this, never been exposed to anyone else. All I've seen growing up is you guys. I can only like the people around me. If it's not Chace, it's Jacen. If it's not Jacen, it's Hayden. Do I have any other choice?"

Caterina IsPunished

788 Mouches

"Tina!" Phillip shouted angrily, causing the entire house to tremble.

"You should be glad that I liked Hayden, not Chace Jacen, after all, Hayden was never one of you..."

"Smack!" Phillip suddenly slapped Tina hard across the face.

Tina was stunned.

From childhood to adulthood, let alone being beaten, Phillip wouldn't even say a harsh word to her. Now, Phillip really hit her.

He slapped her on the face so hard that it seemed like she had gone deaf in her ears.

Tina's tears fell down in big drops.

Her pitiful appearance could no longer elicit sympathy from

anyone.

"Give me the whip!" Phillip's face twisted in a grimace.

The se rvant had actually taken out the whip long ago, but he had been too afraid to hand it to Phillip.

At this moment, I could only give it to him with trepidation.

Phillip said, "Today I must teach you a lesson!"

Tina looked at Phillip in horror.

She was very clear.

She was going to be beaten.

Chapter 4

Phillip was about to punish her cruelly.

Tina trembled all over.

11781 Vouchers

Trembling, she watched as Phillip approached her step by step.

Tina stepped back step by step.

Step by step...

"Snap!" The thick whip mercilessly lashed onto Tina's body.

"Phillip!" Laurel suddenly rushed forward, directly blocking Tina's body.

The whip struck Laurel's body forcefully.

Phillip was clearly startled at that moment. His hand even trembled slightly.

Beside him, Hayden couldn't help but tighten his fist.

This woman is so reckless!

"I told you about Tina's situation, not because I want you to punish her. I just hope that after understanding her feelings, we can help her together," Laurel said loudly to them.