My Ex’s Roommates: A Reverse Harem College Sports Romance (Ex Marks the Spot)
My Ex’s Roommates: Chapter 66

I didn’t deserve Harper but that didn’t mean I wasn’t going to take her. I’d work for her for the rest of my life but right then I just needed her in every way I could have her. I needed to erase the past two weeks with my cock buried inside her ass. I needed the proof that she really was ours.

Kneeling behind her, I could see the way Carter’s cock stretched her pussy and the way her juices coated his shaft. I pulled my finger out of Harper’s ass and grabbed lube from my bedside drawer. Coating my fingers and her ass, I pushed two fingers inside, stretching her as much as I could before feeding her my cock. I didn’t want to hurt her but I needed to be inside her like I needed my next breath.

“Jesus.” Carter swore and thrust his hips up to fuck Harper from below. The sound of their bodies slapping together with her wetness between was damn near pornagraphic and so hot that all three of us groaned in unison.

Silas’ voice was full of gravel as he grasped her hair tight and took her mouth hard and fast. “You’re ours, Harper. No one else will ever touch you. We’re going to protect you and cherish you but we’re also going to fuck you like you’re our filthy little girl. You look so goddamn perfect with my cock buried in your throat. How could we not?”

His words were crass but they worked for us. Harper’s body shook as another wave of her come leaked out around Carter’s thrusts. I took the chance to push another finger deep in her ass and then I fucked her with them. The sounds she made around Silas’ cock were so fucking sexy. Her back flushed red as she shook harder and then stiffened.

Carter swore and then shouted her name as her orgasm triggered his. He filled her with come and it oozed out as he continued to pump into her. I didn’t let up on her ass, pushing her more and more until she screamed and a wave of her come rushed out, soaking Carter and my bed below. She collapsed forward, dislodging Silas’ cock from her mouth, and we watched as she panted and continued to shake. It was insanely hot and I wanted more.

I stroked my cock with more lube and gripped her hips to pull her ass back to me. Her top half stayed flat on Carter’s chest as she struggled to catch her breath. I didn’t give her more time to recover. I needed her. Her head snapped up as soon as I pressed the head of my cock into her ass. I gritted my teeth as her little ring of muscles fought me and then spread to accept my dick. Her body was clamped down on me almost painfully and she came alive as she resisted the stretch.

“Too big!” She reached back to press her hands against my thighs. “Oh, god!”

Carter slid his still hard cock out of her core and it gave her just enough relief. I managed to slide another few inches inside and swore. She was so damn tight.

Silas cupped her face and kissed her, taking his time to relax her while I continued to spear my cock into her virgin ass. Once I was in as deep as I could get, I froze and let her adjust to my size. I had to catch my breath and calm down so I didn’t shoot my load on my first thrust.

“Jesus, princess. Your little ass is taking Dylan so well. It’s so sexy. Your stretched so good, aren’t you? No one else will ever get this.” Silas pushed his thumb into her mouth and groaned when she sucked. “You like this? You like having the three of us going crazy for you? So desperate to have you that we can’t sleep or function without you?”

Harper surprised all of us, even herself, when she spit out his thumb to shout her answer. “Yes! Yes, I like y’all being as obsessed as me!”

Carter nodded to me as he slipped out from under her. “It’s time we teach our little princess not to leave us ever again.”

A shiver worked its way up Harper’s spine. “Please.”

It was all we needed. Silas took Carter’s spot beneath Harper and I had to squeeze my eyes shut and think about anything else when he slowly forced his cock into her pussy. The way her ass got even tighter was insane and I had to fight to keep from coming early. Silas let out a wild growl that told me he was in the same boat.

Harper cried out, her fists hitting Silas’ chest as we both settled deep inside her. She looked back at me with wild eyes and swollen lips. “I need… I… Just move! Please, god, move!”

I pulled out and slowly thrust deep again, watching as her eyes went unfocused and her lips parted on a moan. Our little princess needed to be fucked, it seemed. I just hoped we could last long enough to give her what she needed.

Carter grasped her face and turned it up to his. “Take my cock and taste yourself on me, baby. Suck me deep and feel just how thoroughly we own you.”

“Oh, god, yes!” Harper opened her mouth and then the three of us were filling her to the brim. She flushed between us and shook violently as she came again but it wasn’t as big as she could give us, I knew. I wanted big.

Silas and I found a rhythm quickly. He pulled out while I pushed deep and I pulled out when he pushed deep. We started slower, making sure our princess could handle us but when it was clear by the sounds she made while sucking Carter’s cock that she could take more, we went faster and harder. I gripped her ass tight and spread her cheeks so I could watch her tight little asshole take the pounding my cock was giving it.

The sound of our heavy breathing and moans filled the room and covered Harper’s gags and gargled screams. Carter took her mouth just as hard and fast as we took her body. It was a rough taking, a claiming of what was ours and what we’d never lose again.

We all felt the way her body tightened and I knew the end was close. There was only so much she could handle and only so long I could last with her body milking my cock for all it was worth. Silas and I thrust harder, losing our pace and thrusting deep at the same time. We fucked her hard and fast, driving our dicks as deep as we could get them with the desperate need to mark her.

Carter shouted her name as he came. He held her head tight to his stomach as he came down her throat. Harper swallowed every drop and continued to suck at him until he stumbled away from her mouth. His hand came down and gripped her chin tight. “Such a good girl. Now come for Silas and Dylan.”

Like a trigger, she exploded. Her body slammed down on our cocks and she let out a scream as she squirted again, pushing us over the edge with her. I buried my cock deep in her ass as I shouted her name, coming more than I could ever remember. Silas came at the same time, filling her pussy with his seed.

Time stood still as I tried to get my brain reconnected to the rest of my body. I’d never come so hard and I felt a lot dumber as I sucked in gasps of oxygen and dripped sweat. I felt Silas ease out of her core and heard Harper groan. I didn’t want to hurt her so I forced myself to pull out of her ass as gently as I could. Watching her asshole pulse as my come leaked out had my dick lengthening again but I ignored it and fell to the side, taking Harper with me so she was pinned to my chest.

She continued to shake and moan until I wrapped my body around hers and held her tight. I cupped her pussy, just holding it, and pressed my mouth to her ear to whisper softly.

“I love you, baby.”

Carter lifted his head and grunted. “I love you, too. I’d say it with more passion but I think I’m dead.”

Silas choked out a laugh. “I think you just sucked my brain out through my cock. But I love you, too, princess.”

Holding her even tighter, I kissed her neck. “You’re ours just as much as we’re yours, baby.”

She wiggled her ass into me tighter and sighed. “I love y’all so much. I missed you.”

“Never again, Harper.” I cupped her face and turned her head so she could see me. “What we have is real. If something comes up, we face it together. You’re ours to protect and care for and we won’t take that lightly. Okay?”

Her eyes went misty but she nodded. “Together.”

“I’m going to buy that bed this time, for real.” Carter sat up. “And maybe a big diamond bracelet or necklace. Something that reminds people who you belong to.”

Harper gasped. “Carter! Are you kidding?”

He smirked. “Nope. It seems I’m a possessive bastard when I fall in love.”

I could feel Harper hesitate and then sigh. “It’s hard to be annoyed when you say things like that.”

“Good.” Silas leaned forward and kissed her throat. “I have a feeling we’re going to do a lot of shit to annoy you.”

“Just-”

A loud knock reached all the way to my room from downstairs and then I heard the unmistakable sound of the front door opening. Before I could react, we heard probably the last thing we wanted to hear.

“Harper? It’s time for our dinner!” Her brothers.

Harper gasped and elbowed me in the forehead as she frantically tried to climb out of my bed. “Oh, my god. Oh, my god. This is not happening.”

Silas barely managed to cover his dick before she got it with her knee. “Woman!”

She searched wildly for her clothes and yanked them on as she glared at us. “Get dressed! Jesus, they’re going to know! This is so humiliating.”

Carter growled, got out of bed, and strolled to the door. He opened it a crack and shouted down. “Harper’s in the shower. Give us thirty minutes!”

Danny’s growl filled the room, even from downstairs. “Ten minutes and you better believe I’m hitting one of you when you come down here.”

“Twenty and you hit yourself for going after my sister.”

“What are you doing? Don’t try to negotiate with them!” Harper gripped her hair and then looked down in horror at the space between her thighs. “Oh, god. I’m leaking. I’m leaking your come! I can’t see them like this!”

“Fine. Twenty minutes. We’ll be in the kitchen, touching all of your things, Dylan.”

I grinned at Harper. “If only he knew what all I’d just touched.”

She grabbed a pillow from the floor and threw it at me. “You’re all horrible and you’re lucky I already love you and can’t get out of it now.”

Silas laughed. “You’re damn right you can’t get out of it. Now go take a shower, princess. You smell like sex.”