The Puck Secret (Fairfield U Book 1)
The Puck Secret: Chapter 24

Heat floods my body as my swollen pussy pulses against Nova’s hand. I know he can feel it, I mean fuck, I can smell my arousal from here. Mix that with the touch of his fingers, and Alexander’s eyes focused solely on what his hand covers, I feel like I am about to combust. I have never done anything like this in my life. Hell, until an hour ago, I had never even had casual sex before. It had always been with a guy I was dating, or someone I pretended to like to appease my parents, but Nova pushes every boundary I have, yet I can’t help but think with this new game he is pushing his own even more.

I felt the possessive press of his hands against my skin, saw the look of desperation in his eyes as he fucked me. I felt it in the bathroom, that spark between us, it’s like we both took that hatred we had for one another and turned it into something completely different. Loathing him turned to lusting for him, especially as every inch of his cock sunk inside of me. With him, I’m not the Mayor’s daughter, or Thorne’s future fiancée, I’m not even Josh’s little sister, I am just me, and right now I am his.

His fingers flex against my pussy as he brings his mouth up to my ear. “Truth or dare, Princess?” Nova asks again, and I squirm against his hand as wetness begins to pool between my thighs.

Alexander’s eyes are burning into my flesh, noting every hitch in my breath, and every tremble in my body. I know he’s enjoying this, the same way I am, but how far is this really going to go? I press down into Nova’s body and feel the steel of his cock once again, hard against my ass as I bite back a moan. I know what he wants, what he needs, more than I should, and I don’t feel any regret as I whisper the word, “Dare.”

“Good girl,” he breathes, his hand tightening against my pussy as his middle finger presses against my clit. “I dare you to suck Reign’s cock right here in front of me.”

Alexander curses under his breath at the offer, but his eyes are on his teammate’s, not mine, as they silently communicate with one another, and I don’t even have to look at the two of them to understand. This isn’t about sharing, or having fun, it’s about Nova showing us all who I belong to. About him knowing what I need without me having to ask for it. He wants to teach me that he can give me what I want, and right now, just for tonight, I will happily let him believe he can.

No other words are spoken as Alexander leans forward and places down his drink, before slowly rising to his feet as he decides to play. I watch in fascination as he walks around the table until he is a few inches away from us. Nova remains silent at my back as I stare up at his friend, and just as I open my mouth to say something, Nova’s free hand closes around my throat and pulls me back against him.

“Don’t look at him,” he commands, pushing my face back down to focus on his groin, before squeezing my neck gently and coaxing me towards his teammate. “Come on, Princess, show him what that mouth can do, he’s who you wanted after all, right?”

His hand between my legs releases me, only to smack down hard against me, forcing a moan from my lips, before he slips the middle finger between my pussy and starts to massage my clit. Every fiber in my body starts to heat as he works me with his fingers, and with his grip still around my throat, I reach out with shaky hands and start to undo Alexander’s jeans.

I can feel as he starts to harden beneath my trembling fingers, and when I reach into his boxers to pull him out, he goes rock solid in my hand as I stroke him gently. Nova moves his fingers in time with mine, and when he applies more pressure to my clit I can’t help but cry out again, pressing more into his hold on me.

“Oh god,” I pant, licking my lips as I watch a bead of pre-cum appear at the tip of Alexander’s cock. My brain brings the memory of Nova’s dick against my tongue to the front of my mind, and suddenly I can’t wait to compare. Alexander is just as big as Nova, maybe a little longer, but definitely just as thick, and I almost laugh to myself. No wonder these two constantly have a bunny on their arms, yet here they are about to be undone by little old me.

Nova drags his mouth up and down my neck, teasing me with his tongue, before he pulls my lobe between his teeth. “No point praying now Princess, god doesn’t answer dirty little sluts.” Oh I am going straight to hell, because those words send a jolt of electricity through me, and the only thing I can do to stop it, is lean forward and lick to the head of Alexander’s cock, cleaning up the bead gathered there, and relishing in both their groans.

Alexander steps forward a little, the anticipation of all of this making him needy, and I open my mouth to allow him to slide inside, but before he can get any closer, Nova stops him with a firm hand on his stomach as he warns, “Come inside her mouth, and I will fucking kill you.”

That shouldn’t send a thrill down my spine, but it does, and as the tip of Alexander’s dick slips past my lips, I feel Nova’s grip on my pussy tighten to an almost painful point. I feel more alive than ever before as I suck the head of his cock into my mouth, before pulling back and swirling my tongue around it, in the exact same way I did with Nova.

I can feel Nova watching every move I make, as his fingers start to slide through my own wetness while I moan around Alexander’s cock. I might have another man’s dick in my mouth, but there is no doubt in my mind right now which one of them I belong to. His touch is firm and possessive, playing me like a fiddle as I writhe in his lap, desperate to feel him inside of me again.

His mouth drags along the exposed skin of my neck and shoulder, teasing and tasting me with every swipe of his tongue, before coming back to my ear. “Does he taste as good as I do?”

If my mouth weren’t filled I would tell him no, that despite them being similar, there is no comparison, but all his words do are push me to take his friend deeper, sucking him desperately to the back of my throat as I let my head bob back and forth. Alexander brings his hands up to grip my hair, but then they instantly drop when he hears Nova’s warning. “No fucking touching, Reign.”

My whole body shudders at his demand, his words wrapping around me as his jealousy takes hold. I want more of it, I want to push him, break him, fucking tear him apart like he is doing to me. I moan around Alexander’s length, sucking him and licking him with enthusiasm until he groans out loud, “Her fucking mouth, Darkmore, it’s unreal.”

Nova’s grip on my pussy and throat tightens, holding me against him as he replies to him, “It’s the second best thing I have ever been inside.” The hand between my thighs dips down, and he slides his middle finger inside of me, as his palm starts to grind against my clit, and I choke around Alexander making them both curse.

He thrusts to the back of my throat and spit spills down my chin as I widen my mouth to accommodate his length. Nova continues to fuck me with his hand as I grind down onto him, and Alexander snaps his hips faster and faster as he crawls closer to release. I moan again, vibrating around him as Nova smacks his hand against my pussy even harder, as he chokes me with the other.

The three of us move together as one, yet all of us know that only one person is in charge right now. Nova is all hard at my back, his touch on me possessive and firm, and I have never felt better or more desired in my life. He wants this, he wants me, and right now he owns me enough to make me do this for him. I grind into his hand letting his fingers fuck me, as I desperately buck against him like he didn’t just fuck me in the bathroom. He drives me wild with need, and another moan slips free as I close my eyes and swirl my tongue along the underside of his teammate’s cock.

Alexander is as gone as I am, his hands dropping to my shoulders for support, which Nova must deem a safe place because he doesn’t call him out for it, and all his touch does is push me tighter against his captain. I buck, and grind, and moan between them, desperate to fall apart again, and when Alexander starts to fuck my mouth even harder, tears spill down my face as I gag.

He pulls back slightly, but it’s Nova that grips my hair and pushes me back onto his dick, until my nose is almost against his groin and I gag again. “Mmmm,” Nova grunts, tongue flicking against my ear. “Does your daddy know what you do with that mouth?”

My instinct is to swallow to answer him, but with a mouth full of his friend’s cock it’s impossible, and my action pushes Alexander to the edge. “Fuck, I’m gonna come,” he cries, starting to pull away, but it’s Nova’s grip on my hair that drags my mouth from his cock, as his other hand fucks me even harder.

“Come on her tits,” he demands roughly, his fingers making a wet slapping sound as they slam into me, both of our eyes locked on Alexander as he drags his hand frantically up and down his length, and it’s the sight of him pumping his long, firm cock that has me clamping down around Nova. “That’s it, Princess, cover my fingers in your cum like a little slut, while he covers your tits in his.”

I throw my head back and groan, my orgasm ripping from my body with a scream, as Alexander grunts, ropes of cum shooting from his dick and painting my chest white until we are both panting and breathless.

“Fuck me,” he gasps, his hand still slowly stroking himself as he stares down at the mess he made on my skin.

Nova’s hand still pumps into me gently, sending shivers through my entire body as he tips his chin at his friend. “You had your fun, now fuck off.”

Alexander smiles, rolling his eyes at Nova, but still tucks himself away and turns to leave without another word. I have barely caught my breath before Nova turns me in his lap, his eyes dropping to the release across my chest. Anger and jealousy burn in his stare as he brings his thumb up to rub his teammates cum into my skin, before he curses beneath his breath. Then he is on his feet and carrying us towards the stairs with his hands around my ass.

“What the hell are you doing?” I panic, arms flailing as I hang onto his neck as he begins to ascend the stairs back to the party.

“We are going to my bed,” he grunts, kicking open the door as music starts to thump around us. I feel people’s eyes on us, but Nova doesn’t seem to care, he is on a mission to get us to his room, and all I can do is hang on.

“I’m not staying with you, I barely even know you!” My response is weak, and full of shit, so much so that he laughs. We have known each other for years, but this is different, yet still he ignores me as he storms up to his room.

When we reach his door, he looks at me with fire in his stare as he says, “I’ve had my cock inside of your cunt and your mouth, I think that constitutes as knowing you.” He kicks the door shut behind us, cutting off the bass of the music and the rest of the party, locking the two of us inside together.

My heart thunders hard in my chest as we look at one another, and I can’t seem to drop his stare. It’s intense and demanding. “If those are the rules I better round up the rest of your harem,” I respond breathily, and his eyes darken as he walks us towards his bed.

“Those are only the rules for you,” he says, dropping me to my feet, and reaching down to start dragging my dress down my shoulders. He groans at the sight of my tits, and doesn’t stop until the dress is pooled at my feet.

“I thought you only liked to break the rules?” I ask, teasing him in an attempt to control my anxiety, and the fucker smirks as he pushes me down to sit on the edge of his bed.

“What do you think I’m doing, Princess, I’m about to bang the Mayor’s daughter in my bed, if that isn’t breaking a rule, I don’t know what is.” He drops to his knees as he shucks off his jacket, and then he is unzipping his jeans and dragging his cock through the wetness between my thighs.

I groan, tipping my head back as I push against him and ask, “And letting your friend come on my tits? Was that another rule?” I hear his growl against my neck, as he drops his head to my shoulder and thrusts inside of me without warning.

“That,” he grits out. “Was a test.” He fucks me hard and deep, cutting off any other words from my mouth that aren’t moans of his name, as I hold onto his shoulders and let him own me.

His hands and mouth are everywhere, and when he drops his lips down my neck and across my chest, I groan out loud as he cleans off his teammate’s release from my skin without a care. His movements are fast and erratic like he can’t get enough, like he is trying to lose himself inside of me, and when I feel myself crest towards another orgasm, I grip his face and force his stare to mine, getting lost in his eyes.

We watch each other as he fucks me until I fall apart, clutching his arms as I moan out his name, and I swear it’s like it flips a switch inside of him. I come around his cock and then his rough thrusts turn into slow rolling grinds of his hips, filling me so completely that I can feel myself falling down a hole I won’t be able to escape from.

When he comes this time, it’s with my arms around his neck, and his forehead pressed against mine, as he groans out my name. Our lips are so close they are almost touching, and I can feel his heart beating against my chest in time with my own. His breath is warm against my mouth as he whispers, “Remember who you belong to now, Princess.”

I don’t say a word as he lifts us up, and moves us until I am laying back against one of his pillows. Then he pulls out of me and retreats to the bathroom, returning with a warm wet cloth, and cleaning me up once more before he tosses it aside and loses his jeans, leaving him in just a tank and his boxers. The last thing I remember before falling asleep is him turning off the light and climbing in bed behind me, with the bass of the party still thumping deep beneath us. We crossed a line tonight, one we can’t uncross, and one I want to cross again and again tomorrow.